Small Rewards
Home
/
Store
/
Cat
/
Treats & Rewards
/
Small Rewards
Refine by
Sort by
We recommend
Newest arrivals
Price: Low to High
Price: High to Low
Name: A to Z
Name: Z to A
Filters
Clear all
Filters
Clear all
Price
Clear
Price
Clear
from
–
to
$1
$19
Apply
Apply
Search by SKU
Clear
Search by SKU
Clear
SKU
Apply
Apply
Availability at outlets
Clear
Availability at outlets
Clear
Yorkville
38
1562 1st Ave, Manhattan, New York, NY
Greenwich Village
29
480 Ave of the Americas, Manhattan, New York, NY
Prospect Heights
25
490 Bergen St, Prospect Heights, Brooklyn, NY
Apply
Apply
Search by phrase
Clear
Search by phrase
Clear
Keyword or phrase
Apply
Apply
Sort by
Sort by
We recommend
Newest arrivals
Price: Low to High
Price: High to Low
Name: A to Z
Name: Z to A
Apply
Apply
Show items
Show items
APPLAWS Cat Chicken & Salmon Chew Treats 2oz
APPLAWS Cat Chicken & Salmon Chew Treats 2oz
$4.99
APPLAWS Cat Chicken Chewy Treats 2oz
APPLAWS Cat Chicken Chewy Treats 2oz
$4.99
APPLAWS Cat Tuna Chewy Treats 2oz
APPLAWS Cat Tuna Chewy Treats 2oz
$4.99
APPLAWS Tuna Fillet & Salmon Recipe Natural Crunchy Cat Treats
APPLAWS Tuna Fillet & Salmon Recipe Natural Crunchy Cat Treats
$4.99
Hare Cluck KITTY KITTY 100% Freeze-dried Chicken Treat With Catnip Coating 0.75oz
Hare Cluck KITTY KITTY 100% Freeze-dried Chicken Treat With Catnip Coating 0.75oz
$5.99
OPENFARM Cat Freeze-dried Raw Kitty Cubes Treats, Salmon & Mackerel Recipe 1.5oz
OPENFARM Cat Freeze-dried Raw Kitty Cubes Treats, Salmon & Mackerel Recipe 1.5oz
$8.99
Sold out
OPENFARM Cat Freeze-dried Raw Kitty Cubes Treats, Surf & Turf Recipe 1.5oz
OPENFARM Cat Freeze-dried Raw Kitty Cubes Treats, Surf & Turf Recipe 1.5oz
$8.99
OPENFARM Cat Freeze-dried Raw Kitty Cubes Treats, Chicken & Turkey Recipe 1.5oz
OPENFARM Cat Freeze-dried Raw Kitty Cubes Treats, Chicken & Turkey Recipe 1.5oz
$8.99
ORIJEN Cat Freeze-dried Original Treats 1.25oz
ORIJEN Cat Freeze-dried Original Treats 1.25oz
$8.99
ORIJEN Cat Freeze-dried Tundra Treat 1.25oz
ORIJEN Cat Freeze-dried Tundra Treat 1.25oz
$8.99
ORIJEN Cat Freeze-dried Regional Red Treat 1.25oz
ORIJEN Cat Freeze-dried Regional Red Treat 1.25oz
$8.99
ORIJEN Cat Freeze-dried Treat 6 Fish 1.25oz
ORIJEN Cat Freeze-dried Treat 6 Fish 1.25oz
$9.99
RAWZ Freeze-dried Venison, Goat's Milk & Green Mussels Crunchy Cat Treats
RAWZ Freeze-dried Venison, Goat's Milk & Green Mussels Crunchy Cat Treats
$10.99
RAWZ Freeze-dried Rabbit, Goat's Milk & Green Mussels Crunchy Cat Treats
RAWZ Freeze-dried Rabbit, Goat's Milk & Green Mussels Crunchy Cat Treats
$10.99
RAWZ Freeze-dried Wild Caught Salmon, Goat's Milk & Green Mussels Crunchy Cat Treats
RAWZ Freeze-dried Wild Caught Salmon, Goat's Milk & Green Mussels Crunchy Cat Treats
$10.99
GREENIES Cat Catnip Dental Treat
GREENIES Cat Catnip Dental Treat
$4.99
GREENIES Cat Chicken Treat
GREENIES Cat Chicken Treat
$4.99
GREENIES Cat Healthy Indoor Tuna Flavor
GREENIES Cat Healthy Indoor Tuna Flavor
$4.99
GREENIES Cat Salmon Dental Treat 2.1 Oz
GREENIES Cat Salmon Dental Treat 2.1 Oz
$4.99
GREENIES Cat Skin & Fur Health Chicken Flavor 2.1oz
GREENIES Cat Skin & Fur Health Chicken Flavor 2.1oz
$4.99
APPLAWS Cat Loin Chicken & Rosemary Treats 1.06oz
APPLAWS Cat Loin Chicken & Rosemary Treats 1.06oz
$3.59
APPLAWS Cat Mackeral Loin Treats 1.06oz
APPLAWS Cat Mackeral Loin Treats 1.06oz
$3.59
APPLAWS Cat Loin Salmon Treats 1.06oz
APPLAWS Cat Loin Salmon Treats 1.06oz
$3.59
APPLAWS Cat Tuna Loin Treats 1.06oz
APPLAWS Cat Tuna Loin Treats 1.06oz
$3.59
GREENIES Cat Tuna Dental Treat
GREENIES Cat Tuna Dental Treat
$4.99
Hare Surf KITTY KITTY 100% Freeze-dried White Fish Treat With Krill Coating 0.6oz
Hare Surf KITTY KITTY 100% Freeze-dried White Fish Treat With Krill Coating 0.6oz
$5.99
ICELANDIC Cat Sprat Whole Fish 0.85oz.
ICELANDIC Cat Sprat Whole Fish 0.85oz.
$6.99
KOIRA Cat Minnows 10z
KOIRA Cat Minnows 10z
$10.99
KOIRA Cat Salmon Treats 1.5oz
KOIRA Cat Salmon Treats 1.5oz
$8.99
RAWZ Freeze-dried Minnows Crunchy Cat Treats
RAWZ Freeze-dried Minnows Crunchy Cat Treats
$14.99
SMALL BATCH Dog & Cat Freeze-dried Beef Liver Treat 4oz
SMALL BATCH Dog & Cat Freeze-dried Beef Liver Treat 4oz
$14.99
SMALL BATCH Dog & Cat Freeze-dried Blue Mussel Treat 2oz
SMALL BATCH Dog & Cat Freeze-dried Blue Mussel Treat 2oz
$18.99
SMALL BATCH Dog & Cat Freeze-dried Chicken Hearts 3.5oz
SMALL BATCH Dog & Cat Freeze-dried Chicken Hearts 3.5oz
$17.99
SMALL BATCH Dog & Cat Freeze-dried Beef Hearts 3.5oz
SMALL BATCH Dog & Cat Freeze-dried Beef Hearts 3.5oz
$18.99
SMALL BATCH Dog & Cat Freeze-dried Lamb Hearts 3.5oz
SMALL BATCH Dog & Cat Freeze-dried Lamb Hearts 3.5oz
$17.99
SMALL BATCH Dog & Cat Freeze-dried Chicken Liver Treat 3.5oz
SMALL BATCH Dog & Cat Freeze-dried Chicken Liver Treat 3.5oz
$14.99
SMALL BATCH Dog & Cat Freeze-dried Duck Liver Treat 3oz
SMALL BATCH Dog & Cat Freeze-dried Duck Liver Treat 3oz
$15.99
SMALL BATCH Dog & Cat Freeze-dried Pollock Treat 1.25oz
SMALL BATCH Dog & Cat Freeze-dried Pollock Treat 1.25oz
$14.99
SMALL BATCH Dog & Cat Freeze-dried Lamb Liver Treat 4oz
SMALL BATCH Dog & Cat Freeze-dried Lamb Liver Treat 4oz
$15.99
SMALL BATCH Dog & Cat Freeze-dried Rainbow Trout Treat 2oz
SMALL BATCH Dog & Cat Freeze-dried Rainbow Trout Treat 2oz
$18.99
STELLA & CHEWY'S Cat Meowfulls Freeze-dried Treat Chicken & Liver 1.5oz
STELLA & CHEWY'S Cat Meowfulls Freeze-dried Treat Chicken & Liver 1.5oz
$8.99
WILDFOODIE Freeze-dried Duck Tongues
WILDFOODIE Freeze-dried Duck Tongues
$1.25
WILDFOODIE Freeze - Dried Wild Caught Baby Octupus
WILDFOODIE Freeze - Dried Wild Caught Baby Octupus
$5.99
Skip to main content
Free local delivery $20+ • In-store pick up • Free shipping $50+
Menu
Cat
Dog
Gifts
Our Locations
Customer Care
