Refine by
Sort by
We recommend
Newest arrivals
Price: Low to High
Price: High to Low
Name: A to Z
Name: Z to A
Filters
Clear all
Filters
Clear all
Category
Clear
Category
Clear
Cat
523
Dog
1129
Gifts
1
Apply
Apply
Price
Clear
Price
Clear
from
–
to
$1
$190
Apply
Apply
Search by SKU
Clear
Search by SKU
Clear
SKU
Apply
Apply
Availability at outlets
Clear
Availability at outlets
Clear
Yorkville
1268
1562 1st Ave, Manhattan, New York, NY
Greenwich Village
958
480 Ave of the Americas, Manhattan, New York, NY
Prospect Heights
823
490 Bergen St, Prospect Heights, Brooklyn, NY
Apply
Apply
Search by phrase
Clear
Search by phrase
Clear
Keyword or phrase
Apply
Apply
Sort by
Sort by
We recommend
Newest arrivals
Price: Low to High
Price: High to Low
Name: A to Z
Name: Z to A
Apply
Apply
Show items
Show items
Cat
Dog
Gifts
Featured Products
Gift Card
Gift Card
$25.00 or more
WILDFOODIE Freeze-dried Duck Tongues
WILDFOODIE Freeze-dried Duck Tongues
$1.25
Never Run Out Poop Bag - Turquoise
Never Run Out Poop Bag - Turquoise
$7.99
Never Run Out Poop Bag - Green
Never Run Out Poop Bag - Green
$7.99
OPENFARM Cat Healthy Weight Grain Free Chicken & Whitefish Recipe
OPENFARM Cat Healthy Weight Grain Free Chicken & Whitefish Recipe
$2.69
OPENFARM Cat Digestive Health Grain Free Whitefish & Pollock Recipe
OPENFARM Cat Digestive Health Grain Free Whitefish & Pollock Recipe
$2.69
OPENFARM Cat Hearty Morsels Grain Free Harvest Chicken Recipe 5.3oz
OPENFARM Cat Hearty Morsels Grain Free Harvest Chicken Recipe 5.3oz
$3.19
OPENFARM Cat Skin & Coat Health Grain Free Salmon Recipe
OPENFARM Cat Skin & Coat Health Grain Free Salmon Recipe
$2.69
OPENFARM Cat Hearty Morsels Grain Free Turkey & Salmon Recipe 5.3oz
OPENFARM Cat Hearty Morsels Grain Free Turkey & Salmon Recipe 5.3oz
$3.19
OPENFARM Cat Hearty Morsels Grain Free Chicken & Grass Fed Beef Recipe 5.3oz
OPENFARM Cat Hearty Morsels Grain Free Chicken & Grass Fed Beef Recipe 5.3oz
$3.19
OPENFARM Dog Air Dried Harvest Chicken Recipe 2lbs
OPENFARM Dog Air Dried Harvest Chicken Recipe 2lbs
$51.99
OPENFARM Dog Hearty Stew Grain Free Harvest Chicken Recipe 12.5oz
OPENFARM Dog Hearty Stew Grain Free Harvest Chicken Recipe 12.5oz
$4.79
OPENFARM DOG GOODBOWL GRAIN FREE HARVEST CHICKEN RECIPE 12.5OZ
OPENFARM DOG GOODBOWL GRAIN FREE HARVEST CHICKEN RECIPE 12.5OZ
$3.99
OPENFARM Dog Hearty Stew Grain Free Chicken & Grass Fed Beef Recipe 12.5oz-1
OPENFARM Dog Hearty Stew Grain Free Chicken & Grass Fed Beef Recipe 12.5oz-1
$4.79
OPENFARM Dog Hearty Stew Grain Free Turkey & Salmon Recipe 12.5oz
OPENFARM Dog Hearty Stew Grain Free Turkey & Salmon Recipe 12.5oz
$4.79
OPENFARM Dog Rawmix Great Plains Ancient Grains Recipe 3.5lbs
OPENFARM Dog Rawmix Great Plains Ancient Grains Recipe 3.5lbs
$39.99
OPENFARM Dog Rawmix Great Plains Grain Free Recipe 3.5lbs
OPENFARM Dog Rawmix Great Plains Grain Free Recipe 3.5lbs
$39.99
OPENFARM Dog Rawmix Puppy Ancient Grains Recipe 3.5lbs
OPENFARM Dog Rawmix Puppy Ancient Grains Recipe 3.5lbs
$30.99
OPENFARM Dog Rawmix Puppy Grain Free Recipe 3.5lbs
OPENFARM Dog Rawmix Puppy Grain Free Recipe 3.5lbs
$30.99
K9 NATURAL Dog Core Diets Canned New Zealand Beef Feast 13oz
K9 NATURAL Dog Core Diets Canned New Zealand Beef Feast 13oz
$7.39
WOOF Dog Forager Flyball Single Orange
WOOF Dog Forager Flyball Single Orange
$5.99
TALL TAILS Dog Plush Bee Squeaker Toy 5inches
TALL TAILS Dog Plush Bee Squeaker Toy 5inches
$11.99
STELLA & CHEWY'S Surf 'n Turf Grain Free Dinner Patties Freeze Dried Raw Dog Food - 25 Oz
STELLA & CHEWY'S Surf 'n Turf Grain Free Dinner Patties Freeze Dried Raw Dog Food - 25 Oz
$63.99
K9 NATURAL Dog Core Diets Canned Hoki & New Zealand Beef Feast 13oz
K9 NATURAL Dog Core Diets Canned Hoki & New Zealand Beef Feast 13oz
$7.39
K9 NATURAL Dog Air Dried Grain Free New Zealand Beef Lung Protein Bites 2.1oz
K9 NATURAL Dog Air Dried Grain Free New Zealand Beef Lung Protein Bites 2.1oz
$11.99
FELINE NATURAL Cat Core Diets Freeze-dried Grain Free Chicken & New Zealand Lamb Feast 3.5oz
FELINE NATURAL Cat Core Diets Freeze-dried Grain Free Chicken & New Zealand Lamb Feast 3.5oz
$14.99
K9 NATURAL Dog Core Diets Freeze-dried Grain Free Chicken Feast 17.6oz
K9 NATURAL Dog Core Diets Freeze-dried Grain Free Chicken Feast 17.6oz
$55.99
K9 NATURAL Dog Core Diets Canned New Zealand Lamb & King Salmon Feast 13oz
K9 NATURAL Dog Core Diets Canned New Zealand Lamb & King Salmon Feast 13oz
$7.39
K9 NATURAL Freeze Dried Dog Treats Lamb 1.76
K9 NATURAL Freeze Dried Dog Treats Lamb 1.76
$11.99
K9 Naturalfeline Natural Freeze Dried Pet Food, 1.1-pound, Beef
K9 Naturalfeline Natural Freeze Dried Pet Food, 1.1-pound, Beef
$55.99
FELINE NATURAL Cat Freeze-dried Grain Free Chicken Healthy Bites 1.76oz
FELINE NATURAL Cat Freeze-dried Grain Free Chicken Healthy Bites 1.76oz
$11.99
K9 NATURAL Dog Freeze-dried Grain Free Chicken Healthy Bites 1.76oz
K9 NATURAL Dog Freeze-dried Grain Free Chicken Healthy Bites 1.76oz
$11.99
K9 NATURAL Dog Freeze-dried Grain Free New Zealand Beef Healthy Bites 1.76oz
K9 NATURAL Dog Freeze-dried Grain Free New Zealand Beef Healthy Bites 1.76oz
$11.99
K9 NATURAL Dog Core Diets Freeze-dried Grain Free New Zealand Lamb & King Salmon Feast 17.60z
K9 NATURAL Dog Core Diets Freeze-dried Grain Free New Zealand Lamb & King Salmon Feast 17.60z
$55.99
K9 NATURAL Dog Freeze-dried Grain Free New Zealand Lamb & Venison Feast 3.5oz
K9 NATURAL Dog Freeze-dried Grain Free New Zealand Lamb & Venison Feast 3.5oz
$17.99
FELINE NATURAL Cat Freeze-dried Grain Free New Zealand Lamb & Venison Feast
FELINE NATURAL Cat Freeze-dried Grain Free New Zealand Lamb & Venison Feast
$39.99
K9 NATURAL Chicken Feast Dog Food - 13 Oz
K9 NATURAL Chicken Feast Dog Food - 13 Oz
$7.39
Lamb Feast Dog Food - 13 Oz
Lamb Feast Dog Food - 13 Oz
$7.39
MESSY MUTTS Dog Nonspill Bowl Blue - 5.25 Cup
MESSY MUTTS Dog Nonspill Bowl Blue - 5.25 Cup
$19.99
MESSY MUTTS 628043607361 Mess Dog Nonspill Bowl - Gray - 5.25 Cup - 6 Each Per Case
MESSY MUTTS 628043607361 Mess Dog Nonspill Bowl - Gray - 5.25 Cup - 6 Each Per Case
$19.99
HUXLEY & KENT Cat Pickle
HUXLEY & KENT Cat Pickle
$6.99
HUXLEY & KENT Love Bugs 2pack
HUXLEY & KENT Love Bugs 2pack
$9.99
HUXLEY & KENT Cat Wand Refill 2pack Blue Birdy Feather Teasers
HUXLEY & KENT Cat Wand Refill 2pack Blue Birdy Feather Teasers
$9.99
Sold out
HUXLEY & KENT Cat Wand Refill Purple Birdy Feather Teasers
HUXLEY & KENT Cat Wand Refill Purple Birdy Feather Teasers
$8.99
HUXLEY & KENT Cat Chirpy Cheerful Mouse
HUXLEY & KENT Cat Chirpy Cheerful Mouse
$9.99
HUXLEY & KENT Cat Flinger Goldfish
HUXLEY & KENT Cat Flinger Goldfish
$6.99
HUXLEY & KENT Cat Flinger Butterfly
HUXLEY & KENT Cat Flinger Butterfly
$8.00
HUXLEY & KENT Cat Furrball Assorted Colors
HUXLEY & KENT Cat Furrball Assorted Colors
$5.99
HUXLEY & KENT Cat Nipper Parrot
HUXLEY & KENT Cat Nipper Parrot
$9.99
HUXLEY & KENT Cat Nipper Toucan
HUXLEY & KENT Cat Nipper Toucan
$9.99
HUXLEY & KENT Cat Stuffer Cheddar Cheese Please
HUXLEY & KENT Cat Stuffer Cheddar Cheese Please
$9.99
HUXLEY & KENT Dog Lankies Binky Bunny
HUXLEY & KENT Dog Lankies Binky Bunny
$19.99
HUXLEY & KENT Dog Lankies Luna Unicorn
HUXLEY & KENT Dog Lankies Luna Unicorn
$19.99
HUXLEY & KENT Dog Lankies Red Rooster
HUXLEY & KENT Dog Lankies Red Rooster
$19.99
HUXLEY & KENT Dog Lankies Vincent Van Goat
HUXLEY & KENT Dog Lankies Vincent Van Goat
$19.99
HUXLEY & KENT Dog Power Plush You're Dino-mite
HUXLEY & KENT Dog Power Plush You're Dino-mite
$19.99
HUXLEY & KENT Dog Fetchies Wilma Whale
HUXLEY & KENT Dog Fetchies Wilma Whale
$17.99
HUXLEY & KENT Dog Fetchies Gus Gator Large
HUXLEY & KENT Dog Fetchies Gus Gator Large
$17.99
HUXLEY & KENT Dog Fetchies Gus Gator Small
HUXLEY & KENT Dog Fetchies Gus Gator Small
$14.99
SMALL BATCH Cat Frozen Duck Sliders 3lbs
SMALL BATCH Cat Frozen Duck Sliders 3lbs
$39.99
1 - 60 of 147 items
Prev
1
2
3
Next
Skip to main content
Free local delivery $20+ • In-store pick up • Free shipping $50+
Menu
Cat
Dog
Gifts
Our Locations
Customer Care
