For Picky Cats
Home
/
Store
/
Cat
/
Food & Topper
/
For Picky Cats
FILTER BY:
SEARCH BY PHRASE
Search by phrase
Clear
SEARCH BY PHRASE
Clear
Search by phrase
Keyword or phrase
Apply
Apply
PRICE
Clear
PRICE
Clear
Price
from
–
to
$1
$83
Apply
Apply
SEARCH BY SKU
Clear
SEARCH BY SKU
Clear
Search by SKU
SKU
Apply
Apply
AVAILABILITY AT OUTLETS
Availability at outlets
Clear
AVAILABILITY AT OUTLETS
Clear
Availability at outlets
1562 1st Ave
205
1562 1st Ave, Manhattan, New York, NY
Prospect Heights
95
490 Bergen St, Prospect Heights, Brooklyn, NY
Apply
Apply
SORT BY:
We recommend
We recommend
Newest arrivals
Price: Low to High
Price: High to Low
Name: A to Z
Name: Z to A
TIKI PETS CAT BORN CARNIVORE BABY KITTEN GRAIN FREE CHICKEN & EGGS 2.8LBS
TIKI PETS CAT BORN CARNIVORE BABY KITTEN GRAIN FREE CHICKEN & EGGS 2.8LBS
$29.99
OPENFARM CAT GRAIN FREE LAMB 4LBS
OPENFARM CAT GRAIN FREE LAMB 4LBS
$34.99
Sold out
ORIJEN CAT ORIGINAL 12LB
ORIJEN CAT ORIGINAL 12LB
$77.99
ORIJEN CAT Wild Reserve Kitten 3.5lb
ORIJEN CAT Wild Reserve Kitten 3.5lb
$32.99
OPENFARM CAT GRAIN FREE TURKEY & CHICKEN 4LBS
OPENFARM CAT GRAIN FREE TURKEY & CHICKEN 4LBS
$31.99
ORIJEN CAT Wild Reserve Wild-Caught Fish Recipe 6.5lb
ORIJEN CAT Wild Reserve Wild-Caught Fish Recipe 6.5lb
$54.99
STELLA & CHEWY'S CAT RAW COATED CHICKEN 2.5LB
STELLA & CHEWY'S CAT RAW COATED CHICKEN 2.5LB
$17.99
TIKI PETS CAT BORN CARNIVORE INDOOR HEALTH TROUT AND MENHADEN FISH MEAL RECIPE 3LBS
TIKI PETS CAT BORN CARNIVORE INDOOR HEALTH TROUT AND MENHADEN FISH MEAL RECIPE 3LBS
$23.99
STELLA & CHEWY'S CAT RAW COATED DUCK 2.5LB
STELLA & CHEWY'S CAT RAW COATED DUCK 2.5LB
$17.99
FARMINA CAT N&D PUMPKIN ADULT GRAIN FREE VENISON & APPLE 3.3LBS
FARMINA CAT N&D PUMPKIN ADULT GRAIN FREE VENISON & APPLE 3.3LBS
$33.99
ORIJEN CAT ORIGINAL 4#
ORIJEN CAT ORIGINAL 4#
$32.99
OPENFARM CAT GRAIN FREE KITTEN 4LB
OPENFARM CAT GRAIN FREE KITTEN 4LB
$30.99
TIKI PETS CAT BORN CARNIVORE SILVER SENIOR HEALTH NON -GMO 2.8LBS
TIKI PETS CAT BORN CARNIVORE SILVER SENIOR HEALTH NON -GMO 2.8LBS
$29.99
STELLA & CHEWY'S CAT RAW COATED SALMON 2.5LB
STELLA & CHEWY'S CAT RAW COATED SALMON 2.5LB
$17.99
TIKI PETS CAT BORN CARNIVORE INDOOR HEALTH NON -GMO CHICKEN & TURKEY MEAL 3LBS
TIKI PETS CAT BORN CARNIVORE INDOOR HEALTH NON -GMO CHICKEN & TURKEY MEAL 3LBS
$23.99
Sold out
OPENFARM CAT GRAIN FREE RAWMIX WILD OCEAN 8LBS
OPENFARM CAT GRAIN FREE RAWMIX WILD OCEAN 8LBS
$49.99
ORIJEN CAT REGIONAL RED 4#
ORIJEN CAT REGIONAL RED 4#
$40.99
ORIJEN CAT FIT & TRIM 4#
ORIJEN CAT FIT & TRIM 4#
$36.99
ORIJEN CAT Wild Reserve Free-Run Chicken & Wild-Caught Fish Recipe 3.5lb
ORIJEN CAT Wild Reserve Free-Run Chicken & Wild-Caught Fish Recipe 3.5lb
$32.99
ORIJEN CAT Kitten 4 Lbs
ORIJEN CAT Kitten 4 Lbs
$32.99
RAWZ CAT SALMON CHKN WTFSH 3.5LB
RAWZ CAT SALMON CHKN WTFSH 3.5LB
$32.99
Sold out
RAWZ CAT LID RABBIT RABBIT 7.8LB
RAWZ CAT LID RABBIT RABBIT 7.8LB
$65.99
Sold out
OPENFARM CAT GRAIN FREE WHITEFISH 4LBS
OPENFARM CAT GRAIN FREE WHITEFISH 4LBS
$31.99
ORIJEN CAT Guardian-8 4lb
ORIJEN CAT Guardian-8 4lb
$36.99
ORIJEN CAT Wild Reserve Wild-Caught Fish Recipe 3.5lb Bag
ORIJEN CAT Wild Reserve Wild-Caught Fish Recipe 3.5lb Bag
$34.99
RAWZ CAT LID Real Rabbit Dry Cat Food 1.75lbs
RAWZ CAT LID Real Rabbit Dry Cat Food 1.75lbs
$19.99
ORIJEN CAT Fit & Trim 12lbs
ORIJEN CAT Fit & Trim 12lbs
$82.99
RAWZ CAT Salmon and Chicken & whitefish 1.75lbs
RAWZ CAT Salmon and Chicken & whitefish 1.75lbs
$17.99
TIKI PETS CAT BORN CARNIVORE HIGH PROTEIN GRAIN FREE CHICKEN HERRING & SALMON MEAL 2.8LBS
TIKI PETS CAT BORN CARNIVORE HIGH PROTEIN GRAIN FREE CHICKEN HERRING & SALMON MEAL 2.8LBS
$29.99
OPENFARM CAT GRAIN FREE RAWMIX PRAIRIE 2.25LBS
OPENFARM CAT GRAIN FREE RAWMIX PRAIRIE 2.25LBS
$21.99
RAWZ CAT Chicken, Turkey & chicken 1.75lbs.
RAWZ CAT Chicken, Turkey & chicken 1.75lbs.
$17.99
ORIJEN CAT 6 FISH 4#
ORIJEN CAT 6 FISH 4#
$36.99
ORIJEN CAT Guardian Senior 4lbs
ORIJEN CAT Guardian Senior 4lbs
$36.99
RAWZ CAT Chicken & Turkey All Life Stages 3.5LB
RAWZ CAT Chicken & Turkey All Life Stages 3.5LB
$32.99
TIKI PETS CAT BORN CARNIVORE HIGH PROTEIN GRAIN FREE DEBONED CHICKEN & EGG 2.8LBS
TIKI PETS CAT BORN CARNIVORE HIGH PROTEIN GRAIN FREE DEBONED CHICKEN & EGG 2.8LBS
$29.99
RAWZ CAT LID RABBIT 3.5LB
RAWZ CAT LID RABBIT 3.5LB
$35.99
ORIJEN CAT TUNDRA 4#
ORIJEN CAT TUNDRA 4#
$50.99
NATURAL BALANCE CAT LID GREEN PEA & VENISON RECIPE 4LBS
NATURAL BALANCE CAT LID GREEN PEA & VENISON RECIPE 4LBS
$29.99
Sold out
ORIJEN CAT Wild Reserve Free-Run Chicken & Wild-Caught Fish Recipe 6.5lb
ORIJEN CAT Wild Reserve Free-Run Chicken & Wild-Caught Fish Recipe 6.5lb
$51.99
RAWZ CAT digestive support rabbit & cranberry recipe +Prebiotic Fiber & Fenugreek 5.5oz.
RAWZ CAT digestive support rabbit & cranberry recipe +Prebiotic Fiber & Fenugreek 5.5oz.
$4.29
ZIWI CAT RABBIT & LAMB 3OZ
ZIWI CAT RABBIT & LAMB 3OZ
$4.39
KOHA CAT LIMITED INGREDIENT PATE GRAIN FREE TURKEY 3OZ
KOHA CAT LIMITED INGREDIENT PATE GRAIN FREE TURKEY 3OZ
$1.89
FELINE NATURAL CAT GRAIN FREE CANNED NEW ZEALAND LAMB & VENISON FEAST 3OZ - 24 PACK
FELINE NATURAL CAT GRAIN FREE CANNED NEW ZEALAND LAMB & VENISON FEAST 3OZ - 24 PACK
$3.19
RAWZ CAT 96% Rabbit & Pumpkin Pâté 5.5oz
RAWZ CAT 96% Rabbit & Pumpkin Pâté 5.5oz
$4.79
Rawz 96% cat rabbit & pumpkin pâté 3oz
Rawz 96% cat rabbit & pumpkin pâté 3oz
$3.19
LOTUS C JUICY STEW SALMON & POLLOCK 2.5OZ
LOTUS C JUICY STEW SALMON & POLLOCK 2.5OZ
$2.99
TIKI PETS CAT GRILL TUNA & CRAB SURIMI 2.8OZ
TIKI PETS CAT GRILL TUNA & CRAB SURIMI 2.8OZ
$2.09
RAWZ CAT Gravy Tuna & Mackerel Recipe 3oz
RAWZ CAT Gravy Tuna & Mackerel Recipe 3oz
$2.19
TURLUXE CAT MEDITERRANEAN HARVEST 6OZ
TURLUXE CAT MEDITERRANEAN HARVEST 6OZ
$3.19
ZIWI CAT VENISON 3OZ
ZIWI CAT VENISON 3OZ
$4.39
Rawz 96% Cat rabbit pâté 3oz
Rawz 96% Cat rabbit pâté 3oz
$3.19
TRULUXE CAT CLASSIC MEDITERRANEAN HARVEST WITH VEGETABLE 3OZ
TRULUXE CAT CLASSIC MEDITERRANEAN HARVEST WITH VEGETABLE 3OZ
$2.49
TRULUXE CAT CLASSIC QUICK 'N QUIRKY 3OZ
TRULUXE CAT CLASSIC QUICK 'N QUIRKY 3OZ
$2.49
ZIWI CAT MACKEREL 3OZ
ZIWI CAT MACKEREL 3OZ
$3.19
TRULUXE CAT CLASSIC QUICK 'N QUIRKY 6OZ
TRULUXE CAT CLASSIC QUICK 'N QUIRKY 6OZ
$3.79
TIKI PETS CAT LUAU CHICKEN & EGGS 2.8OZ
TIKI PETS CAT LUAU CHICKEN & EGGS 2.8OZ
$2.49
TIKI PETS CAT LUAU SUCCULENT CHICKEN 2.8OZ
TIKI PETS CAT LUAU SUCCULENT CHICKEN 2.8OZ
$2.49
WERUVA CAT ASIAN FUSION 3OZ
WERUVA CAT ASIAN FUSION 3OZ
$1.99
TIKI PETS CAT LUAU WILD SALMON 2.8OZ
TIKI PETS CAT LUAU WILD SALMON 2.8OZ
$2.49
CATS IN THE KITCHEN LA ISLA BONITA 3.2OZ
CATS IN THE KITCHEN LA ISLA BONITA 3.2OZ
$1.99
1 - 60 of 240 items
Prev
1
2
3
4
Next
Skip to main content
Free local delivery $20+ • In-store pick up • Free shipping $50+
Profile
Wishlist
Cart
Catalog
Search
Our Locations
Customer care
Profile
Wishlist
Cart
Search
