For Picky Cats
Home
/
Store
/
Cat
/
Food & Topper
/
For Picky Cats
Refine by
Sort by
We recommend
Newest arrivals
Price: Low to High
Price: High to Low
Name: A to Z
Name: Z to A
Filters
Clear all
Filters
Clear all
Price
Clear
Price
Clear
from
–
to
$1
$51
Apply
Apply
Search by SKU
Clear
Search by SKU
Clear
SKU
Apply
Apply
Availability at outlets
Clear
Availability at outlets
Clear
Yorkville
69
1562 1st Ave, Manhattan, New York, NY
Prospect Heights
43
490 Bergen St, Prospect Heights, Brooklyn, NY
Greenwich Village
28
480 Ave of the Americas, Manhattan, New York, NY
Apply
Apply
Search by phrase
Clear
Search by phrase
Clear
Keyword or phrase
Apply
Apply
Sort by
Sort by
We recommend
Newest arrivals
Price: Low to High
Price: High to Low
Name: A to Z
Name: Z to A
Apply
Apply
Show items
Show items
OPENFARM Cat Grain Free Lamb 4lbs
OPENFARM Cat Grain Free Lamb 4lbs
$34.99
Sold out
STELLA & CHEWY'S Cat Raw Coated Duck 2.5lb
STELLA & CHEWY'S Cat Raw Coated Duck 2.5lb
$17.99
ORIJEN Cat Regional Red 4#
ORIJEN Cat Regional Red 4#
$40.99
Sold out
OPENFARM Cat Grain Free Rawmix Prairie 2.25lbs
OPENFARM Cat Grain Free Rawmix Prairie 2.25lbs
$21.99
RAWZ Cat Lid Rabbit
RAWZ Cat Lid Rabbit
$35.99
ORIJEN Cat Tundra 4#
ORIJEN Cat Tundra 4#
$50.99
Natural Balance Cat Lid Green Pea & Venison Recipe 4lbs
Natural Balance Cat Lid Green Pea & Venison Recipe 4lbs
$29.99
FELINE NATURAL Cat Grain Free Canned New Zealand Lamb & Venison Feast 3oz - 24 Pack
FELINE NATURAL Cat Grain Free Canned New Zealand Lamb & Venison Feast 3oz - 24 Pack
$3.19
RAWZ 96% Cat Rabbit & Pumpkin Pâté
RAWZ 96% Cat Rabbit & Pumpkin Pâté
$3.19
LOTUS C Juicy Stew Salmon & Pollock 2.5oz
LOTUS C Juicy Stew Salmon & Pollock 2.5oz
$2.99
TIKI PETS Cat Grill Tuna & Crab Surimi 2.8oz
TIKI PETS Cat Grill Tuna & Crab Surimi 2.8oz
$2.09
Turluxe Cat Mediterranean Harvest 6oz
Turluxe Cat Mediterranean Harvest 6oz
$3.19
Cats In The Kitchen Cat Pumpkin Jack Splash 3oz Pouch
Cats In The Kitchen Cat Pumpkin Jack Splash 3oz Pouch
$1.99
RAWZ Cat 96% Rabbit Pâté
RAWZ Cat 96% Rabbit Pâté
$3.19
Cats In The Kitchen Cat Mack Jack & Sam 3oz Pouch
Cats In The Kitchen Cat Mack Jack & Sam 3oz Pouch
$1.99
Truluxe Cat Classic Mediterranean Harvest With Vegetable 3oz
Truluxe Cat Classic Mediterranean Harvest With Vegetable 3oz
$2.49
Truluxe Cat Classic Quick 'n Quirky
Truluxe Cat Classic Quick 'n Quirky
$2.49
Cats In The Kitchen La Isla Bonita 3.2oz
Cats In The Kitchen La Isla Bonita 3.2oz
$1.99
TIKI PETS Cat Grill Sardine Cutlets In Lobster Consomme 2.8oz
TIKI PETS Cat Grill Sardine Cutlets In Lobster Consomme 2.8oz
$2.09
Truluxe Cat Classic On The Cat Wok
Truluxe Cat Classic On The Cat Wok
$2.49
KOHA Cat Limited Ingredient Grain Free Venison Pate
KOHA Cat Limited Ingredient Grain Free Venison Pate
$3.09
Cats In The Kitchen Two Tu Tango 3.2oz
Cats In The Kitchen Two Tu Tango 3.2oz
$1.99
TIKI PETS Cat Grill Ahi Tuna 2.8oz
TIKI PETS Cat Grill Ahi Tuna 2.8oz
$2.09
KOHA Cat Limited Ingredient Pate Grain Free Rabbit 3oz
KOHA Cat Limited Ingredient Pate Grain Free Rabbit 3oz
$3.09
TIKI PETS Cat Grill Sardine Cutlets 2.8oz
TIKI PETS Cat Grill Sardine Cutlets 2.8oz
$2.09
Cats In The Kitchen Cat Pumpkin Lickin Chicken 3oz Pouch
Cats In The Kitchen Cat Pumpkin Lickin Chicken 3oz Pouch
$1.99
FELINE NATURAL Cat Grain Free Canned New Zealand Chicken & King Salmon Feast 3oz
FELINE NATURAL Cat Grain Free Canned New Zealand Chicken & King Salmon Feast 3oz
$3.19
TIKI PETS Cat Grill Mackerel & Sardine 2.8oz
TIKI PETS Cat Grill Mackerel & Sardine 2.8oz
$2.09
Cats In The Kitchen Cat 1 By Land 2 By Sea 3oz Pouch
Cats In The Kitchen Cat 1 By Land 2 By Sea 3oz Pouch
$1.99
WERUVA Truluxe Cat Classic Kawa Booty 3oz
WERUVA Truluxe Cat Classic Kawa Booty 3oz
$2.49
Truluxe Cat Classic Peking Ducken
Truluxe Cat Classic Peking Ducken
$2.49
TIKI PETS Cat Grill Ahi Tuna & Crab 2.8oz
TIKI PETS Cat Grill Ahi Tuna & Crab 2.8oz
$2.09
RAWZ Shredded Chicken & Duck Recipe Adult
RAWZ Shredded Chicken & Duck Recipe Adult
$3.39
TIKI PETS Cat After Dark Chicken 2.8oz
TIKI PETS Cat After Dark Chicken 2.8oz
$2.69
Cats In The Kitchen Kitty Gone Wild 3.2oz
Cats In The Kitchen Kitty Gone Wild 3.2oz
$1.99
Cats In The Kitchen Chicken Frik 'a Zee 3.2oz
Cats In The Kitchen Chicken Frik 'a Zee 3.2oz
$1.99
Cats In The Kitchen Lamb Burger-ini 3.2oz
Cats In The Kitchen Lamb Burger-ini 3.2oz
$1.99
Cats In The Kitchen Cat Love Me Tender 3oz Pouch
Cats In The Kitchen Cat Love Me Tender 3oz Pouch
$1.99
FELINE NATURAL Cat Grain Free Beef & Hoki 3oz
FELINE NATURAL Cat Grain Free Beef & Hoki 3oz
$3.19
Tiki Cat After Dark Grain Free Chicken & Quail Egg Recipe In Broth 2.8oz.
Tiki Cat After Dark Grain Free Chicken & Quail Egg Recipe In Broth 2.8oz.
$2.69
ORIJEN Cat Chunks Beef & Tuna Entree 3oz
ORIJEN Cat Chunks Beef & Tuna Entree 3oz
$2.79
ORIJEN Cat Chunks & Shreds Duck & Liver Entree
ORIJEN Cat Chunks & Shreds Duck & Liver Entree
$3.99
FELINE NATURAL Cat Grain Free Lamb 3oz
FELINE NATURAL Cat Grain Free Lamb 3oz
$3.19
Cats In The Kitchen Goldie Lox 3.2oz
Cats In The Kitchen Goldie Lox 3.2oz
$1.99
Cats In The Kitchen The Double Dip 3.2oz
Cats In The Kitchen The Double Dip 3.2oz
$1.99
ORIJEN Cat Entree Duck & Chicken 3oz
ORIJEN Cat Entree Duck & Chicken 3oz
$2.79
TIKI PETS Cat After Dark Chicken & Quail Egg 2.8oz
TIKI PETS Cat After Dark Chicken & Quail Egg 2.8oz
$2.69
FELINE NATURAL Cat Grain Free Lamb & Salmon 3oz
FELINE NATURAL Cat Grain Free Lamb & Salmon 3oz
$3.19
Cats In The Kitchen Fowl Ball 3.2oz
Cats In The Kitchen Fowl Ball 3.2oz
$1.99
Truluxe Cat Classic Steak Frites Dinner
Truluxe Cat Classic Steak Frites Dinner
$2.49
Tiki Pet Cat After Dark Beef & Beef Liver 3oz
Tiki Pet Cat After Dark Beef & Beef Liver 3oz
$2.69
TIKI PETS Cat After Dark Chicken 2.8 Oz
TIKI PETS Cat After Dark Chicken 2.8 Oz
$2.69
Truluxe Cat Classic Pretty In Pink 3oz
Truluxe Cat Classic Pretty In Pink 3oz
$2.49
WERUVA Truluxe Cat Classic Honor Roll 3oz
WERUVA Truluxe Cat Classic Honor Roll 3oz
$2.49
TIKI PETS Cat After Dark Chicken & Duck 2.8oz
TIKI PETS Cat After Dark Chicken & Duck 2.8oz
$2.69
TIKI PETS Cat After Dark Pate Rabbit & Chicken Liver 3oz
TIKI PETS Cat After Dark Pate Rabbit & Chicken Liver 3oz
$2.69
Cats In The Kitchen Cat Chick Magnet 3oz Pouch
Cats In The Kitchen Cat Chick Magnet 3oz Pouch
$1.99
FELINE NATURAL Cat Grain Free Chicken & Lamb 3oz
FELINE NATURAL Cat Grain Free Chicken & Lamb 3oz
$3.19
RAWZ Cat 96% Duck & Duck Liver Pâté 5.5oz
RAWZ Cat 96% Duck & Duck Liver Pâté 5.5oz
$3.99
FELINE NATURAL Cat Grain Free Chicken & Venison 3oz
FELINE NATURAL Cat Grain Free Chicken & Venison 3oz
$3.19
1 - 60 of 84 items
Prev
1
2
Next
Skip to main content
Free local delivery $20+ • In-store pick up • Free shipping $50+
Menu
Cat
Dog
Gifts
Our Locations
Customer Care
